The Elkins Baseball Hall of Fame was created in the fall of 2004 by former head coach Rick Carpenter as a way to honor players, coaches, and administrators for their contributions to the Baseball Program.
2005: Jason Gray, Ivan Heredia, Royce Huffman, Eric Nelson, Mike Scarborough, Kip Wells
2006: Kelly Eddlemon, Jason Kirchner, Shawn Thompson, Steven Truitt
2007: Myron Johnson, Scott Huffman, Jason Slanina, Kevin Lawson, James Loney, Wardell Starling
2008: Rick Carpenter
2009: Brad Detmore, David Leatherwood, Mike Petersen, James Patterson
2010: Andy Boland, Chad Huffman, Kelly Shearer, Mike Susaneck
2011: Kevin Eddlemon, Patrick Penry, Luis Venitucci
2012: Matt Carpenter, Spencer Jackson, Tony Mardirosian, Josh Plumaj
2013: Ron Beard, Will Carpenter, Stephen Porlier, Grant Taylor
2014: Kyle Bates, Blake Bradbury, Tyler Carpenter, Clint Vest
2015: Ted Harris
2016: Duke Dykeman, Kevin Max, Dan Tuskowski